Members can sign in here.

About the Author

Luan Galani
Science & Development Journalist (Curitiba, Brazil)

A twenty-something eternal apprentice who has a passionate interest in what happens around him. Fascinated by the under-reported, he refuses to be a detached observer and never tires of exploring the untold. His long-life dream is reporting from conflict zones to dig up the underbelly side of war.

Post

AN INTERNATIONALLY FAMOUS CITY

Published 04th June 2010 - 11 comments - 5143 views -

Firstly, before going straight to the result of my immersion, it is highly necessary to sketch a picture of the city where I live.  We can not simply talk only on Favelas. As Tiziana highlighted (although talking about Africa, it is also applicable to Brazil), we have to show good things as well, to look on the bright side.

Some cities were given a surprisingly special present: a place on the list of The World's Smartest Cities. As the author of this list says, being smart is not simply a synonym of being green. It requires a three-legged key stool of strong infrastructure, attractive economy and savvy urban planning. Among these ten special “god-blessed places”, imagine my flabbergasted feeling at breakfast time when I saw my home town at the top.

The American magazine reckoned to be always remembered for its attention-grabbing lists delivered one more. This time Forbes is all about "The World's Smartest Cities". Its author is the widely-published North-American journalist Joel Kotkin, Presidential Fellow in Urban Futures at Chapman University, in California, and Adjunct at the Legatum Institute based in London. The 10 now famous cities chosen by him are:

No.1 - Singapore, Singapore

No.2 - Hong Kong, China

No.3 - Curitiba, Brazil

No.4 - Monterrey, Mexico

No.5 - Amsterdam, the Netherlands

No.6 - Seattle, USA

No.7 - Houston, USA

No.8 - Charleston, USA

No.9 - Huntsville, USA

No.10 - Calgary, Canada

The only remaining question is what a 'smart city' is. Nowadays, a smart city refers to a place with a green sustainable agenda. Yet it has characterized successful cities in the past, now there is other important factors that must be taken into account to label a city as smart. Like a strong infrastructure, an attractive economy and a savvy urban planning.

These criteria exclude straightaway behemoth cities like New York, Tokyo, Mexico City or São Paulo, which suffer from huge traffic congestion, out-of-control estate prices and expanding income disparities, what in this case leads directly to a seething mass of violence. They are the beholders of what the American urban historian Lewis Mumford calls ‘megalopolitan elephantiasis’.

Instead, in Kotkin words, "smart cities tend to be smaller, compact and more efficient". And this seems not to be a one-off new idea. As the North-American journalist wrote, between the 14th and 18th centuries, modest-sized cities like Venice and Antwerp not only created vibrant urban quarters but nurtured modern capitalism. What comes to reinforce the disputable proverb that good things come in small packages.

More, Curitiba was recently awarded with the Globe Award Sustainable City Stockholm, Sweden. The decision was unanimity among judges. My city disputed with Sydney (Australia), Malmö (Sweden), Murcia (Spain), Songpa (South Korea) and Stargard Szczecinski (Poland).

Small southern package of Brazil

 The south Brazilian city of Curitiba, which is in the third place on the Forbes list, is regarded worldwide as an innovator in everything from bus-based rapid transit, used by the majority (75%) of its residents, till its balanced economic development strategy.

With a population of 3.5 million citizens, Curitiba demonstrates how to achieve the evolving Brazilian dream without the mass violence, transport dysfunction and ubiquitous grinding poverty that plague many other Latin American areas. The city's program of building "Lighthouses of Knowledge" - essentially libraries and art spaces - on the outskirts of the central core of the city for poorer inhabitants has become a model for developing cities. These are among the reasons Reader's Digest recently named Curitiba the best place to live in Brazil.

Speaking exclusively, the award-winning architect Jaime Lerner - three times mayor of Curitiba, urbanization consultant for the UN and former president of the International Union of Architects based in Paris – was emphatic when remembering the urban revolution he had led. "Curitiba was and always will be an important reference. It shows that a lot of things are possible if there is strong commitment to simplicity and will-power, what guarantees the vanguard position of the city", he says.

(Jaime Lerner)

Nowadays, 83 cities around the world are using the transport system created by Lerner in Curitiba, like Seul, Mexico City and Los Angeles. Compared to eight other Brazilian cities of its size, Curitiba uses about 30 percent less fuel per capita because of this system, resulting in one of the lowest rates of ambient air pollution in the country. Its bus system plays a large part in making this a livable city. Consequently, Curitiba has one of the most heavily used, yet low-cost, transit systems in the world. It offers many of the features of a subway system - vehicle movements unimpeded by traffic signals and congestion, fare collection prior to boarding, quick passenger loading and unloading - but it is above ground and visible.

Founded in 1693 from a tiny explorers' village, this first Brazilian city to implement a University had become an important trading site that strengthen itself with the arrival of European immigrants - from Germany, Italy, Poland and Japan - in the 19th century.

And differently from other cities, in Curitiba there is still enough room to expand, and that is why so many companies have been allured to bring in their business and industries, like Exxon Mobil and HSBC.

But is Curitiba so colourful as painted in foreign magazines and was Jaime Lerner such a good politician?

I do not think so.

Soon, you will be able to draw your own conclusions…

 

Images courtesy of Jaime Lerner and the Town hall of Curitiba.

 


Category: Media | Tags: curitiba, green city, jaime lerner,


Comments

  • Giedre Steikunaite on 05th June 2010:

    Hey Luan, thank you for introducing Curitiba, it seems to be a great place. The video, being an ad, shows just one side of course. I’m wondering, all these nice things they show there, are they just for the rich? I know you went to a favela and a story will follow, but talking about this “nice side”, how affordable is all that to an average citizen? I mean, do people earn enough to actually be able to visit a museum and buy a necklace in that crafts market, for example? Because a city can have amazing things, but if only the money-haves can make use of them, it’s same old story of inequality then.


  • Clare Herbert on 12th June 2010:

    What a beautiful place. You’re lucky to live somewhere so lovely.


  • Iris Cecilia Gonzales on 12th June 2010:

    I like the photos! Wow. It’s the first time I read about Curitiba.


  • Luan Galani on 14th June 2010:

    First of all, I’m sorry for my delayed response.

    Again, thank you so much for your opinion. It is always very important for me.

    @Clare, indeed, I’m lucky and I wouldn’t live anywhere else, I think wink

    @Iris, like you, almost everyone in our meeting in Brussels had never heard about Curitiba. I thought it so strange…but now you know, right?

    @Giedre, a very good question. But it is not only for the rich.
    In comparison to São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro, Curitiba is far cheaper. It is affordable for all.

    All cultural activities are free of charge on Sundays (plays, expositions etc) and many (I mean a lot, really) museums are for free. Philharmonic and Symphony orchestras play for free once a month, parks are always open for all…

    Well, based on my experiences, people here can buy necklaces and visit museums. Of course, there are some income and social disparities, but, in general, everyone can afford.

    Thanks for this question…very clarifying. =)


  • Giedre Steikunaite on 14th June 2010:

    Free museums and other cultural activities are indeed a very good thing. If the city is affordable to everyone, that’s just great!

    Waiting for your favela story Luan! wink


  • Clare Herbert on 15th June 2010:

    @Luan: Except maybe Ireland wink


  • Daniel Nylin Nilsson on 26th June 2010:

    Free culture for the people is in deed important. I think everyone agrees how important culture is to society, especially if we are trying to build other values like solidarity and enviornmentalism. But when start paying for culture it becomes something different - we use it as a way to show off, and some people don’t use it at all.


  • Bill Hinchberger on 13th August 2010:

    Further Reading

    Curitiba: Jaime Lerner’s Urban Acupuncture: http://www.brazilmax.com/news.cfm/tborigem/pl_south/id/10

    Curitiba, Brazil: Urban Renewal, Municipal Revitalization: http://www.brazilmax.com/news.cfm/tborigem/pl_south/id/9


  • Luan Galani on 23rd August 2010:

    Thanks for the links, Bill wink Always welcome…


  • Frank on 14th February 2011:

    My wife and I (and our little daughter) have been living in Fortaleza for just over 2 years now, and in another year we’re been planning to move to another city. Recently I’ve been investigating many of the medium to large size cities in Brazil and have even prepared a conversation class (I teach English) to get all of my students’ opinions on the best city to live in Brazil… and I can tell you it’s not an easy matter. For starters, I would prefer living in a coastal city… I love the beach… but I think this post may have just given me that little push that I need to start thinking about moving away from the beach - to Curitiba off course. It looks like an incredible place for families. It reminds me a lot of San Jose, Costa Rica - but more modern and organized! Thanks for the awesome info… I already showed the youtube videos to my wife, and she was convinced smile


  • Luan Galani on 10th April 2011:

    Frank, thank you very much for your kind words. Curitiba is indeed a very nice place to live, in which many projects and spearheading initiatives take place. But, as you has already pointed out, you would have to think carefully before moving. Here violence is growing in general, as part of a world trend, and most people may not be as friendly as in coastal towns. Feel free to contact me via email if you have any questions.


Post your comment

  • Remember my personal information

    Notify me of follow-up comments?

    --- Let's see if you are human ---

    What is missing: North, South, West? Add a questionmark to your answer. (5 character(s) required)