Members can sign in here.

Post

Does the source of help matter?

Published 21st August 2010 - 3 comments - 885 views -

Image comes from the BBC News "Pakistan floods 'hit 14m people'" published on August 6 2010.

 

At the beginning of August, Pakistan was hit by one of the worst floods ever in its history. Lives of around 14 million people were affected by floodwaters and mudslides destroying houses, crops and whole villages. Furthermore, the situation may still get worse as it is only the middle of monsoon season and further downpours are predicted.

This is the formal part of news to be found on BBC website and other news agencies.
But when I heard this news for the first time in Polish radio what struck me the most was a comment, or rather further part of information given. Lady with a nice emotionless voice informed listeners that some help to destroyed provinces of Punjab and Sindh may come from foreign donors but aid was already offered to devastated lands by islamist groups and that Western countries and state administration are afraid that such actions could bring more power and support to these groups accused of terrorist attacks in Mumbai.

This made me wonder. On the one hand we have a group banned in Pakistan for its links with attacks in Mumbai. On the other hand, these same people are able to bring help quickly and respond effectively to desperate needs of millions who lost with floods almost everything. Which side matters more? And why are we only afraid of growing influence of such islamist groups if they get their support through aid and bringing relief? Why instead cannot we, meaning states and countries so 'afraid', cannot mobilize ourselves to do our aid job better? Why don't we spend more money on this instead of guns and weapons? Why are we so inconsistent in our words and actions??

Even though this conclusion may sound trivial I was struck how many examples of our 'misbehaviour' we can find in our daily lives. And how good it would be if we finally saw development as means to achieve also 'our' goals.
 


Category: Aid | Tags:


Comments

  • Andrea Arzaba on 21st August 2010:

    Thisis a very interesting topic! Thank you!

    So…people might be “afraid of growing influence of islamist groups”. Huuummm what is more important: Savung lives or being aware of an ideology and juding because of this situation?

    This is an emergency! I think that the answer is obvious!


  • Helena Goldon on 23rd August 2010:

    “Why instead cannot we, meaning states and countries so ‘afraid’, cannot mobilize ourselves to do our aid job better?” - agree 100%, Gosia.


  • Hussam Hussein on 29th August 2010:

    Hi Gosia, thanks for your article! you raised a very interesting issue, similar for instance to the discussion we had in class I think concerning foreign aid in Africa: China/EU competition (including the conditionality EU principle versus the non conditionality or the political Chinese condition of the one China principle). Thanks!


Post your comment

  • Remember my personal information

    Notify me of follow-up comments?

    --- Let's see if you are human ---

    Mel Gibson, is he a car mechanic or an actor? Add a questionmark to your answer. (6 character(s) required)