Members can sign in here.

About the Author

Hemant Jain
Writer, designer (Mumbai, India)

I am a writer and illustrator. I like to tell stories about the world I live in and keep a tab on India's environmental crimes here: http://greatindiansale.blogspot.com/

Post

There should only be one Millennium Development Goal. Redefine development.

Published 25th April 2010 - 8 comments - 3965 views -


This is Mumbai. The city of dreams. This is where people from all across India come to chase their dreams and very often, they chase them successfully.
This is Mumbai where I live. Behind this water tanker is my building. It used to be a rather green area. Then the builder traded each clump of trees for a building. Now, there are shrubs, a few, and a lot of dust.
Dust that never settles down.
The rumble of these antique trucks kicks up the dust till it hangs sort of permanently in mid air.
These trucks are water tankers. My building receives several of those every single day. They carry water mercilessly pumped out of the ground. 
Today that water tanker guy said there is no more plentiful water in the ground. There will be short supply of water. (Not very different from the rest of India whose water tables are dangerously drying up according to this NASA report).
I have two 20 litre buckets of water filled with water so I can go about my daily life. The water is brown in colour. It contains the dregs of overhead cement tank, dust and I am sure microbes in millions.
I drink bottled water to help me survive acute diseases.
The coming days look tough and dry. I, like whole of India, long for the rains.
This is Mumbai. The heart of India’s development story. Mumbai - India’s answer to New York. Mumbai - India’s Shanghai. Or Dubai.
Or, a cesspool of development gone wrong?

If this is the development we are killing our tribals for, then God help us. Yes you heard it right. India is in the midst of the ‘biggest social engineering’ that the world has ever seen. (click to read in detail and see specially Arundhati Roy's essay) We want to dispossess and drive out countless millions who live in India. Their crime: they live on mineral rich land.
India is supposedly in the grips of Maoism. Maoists are fighting the government, and the government is driving them out. It’s all a little too convenient.
Here’s why.
All the Maoist affected areas are also the mineral rich areas.
Government has signed treaties with mining companies.
The problem is that the fifth schedule of our constitution gives rights over this land to the tribals.
But to remove the Maoists from these areas, the tribals will have to be shunted out.
No tribals, no rights. land becomes free.
For all the tribals who stay on the land and protest that it is their land, the strategy is simple: Label them Maoists. And hunt them down.
The genocide in India has begun and if you, as a foreign journalist, want to go to places like Dantewada and see what is happening, god forbid. You will not be granted a visa. Ask your friends who work for Channel 4 and other such if what I am saying is wrong.
Here is an easy to understand look at what is happening. Read the debate which follows. It will give you a fair understanding of what some educated Indians feel.

But of course there are 350 million people in India living in cities who fuel the consumerist fire. Who make India grow at a phenomenal 8% growth. Our government promises that we will keep growing at 8%. And we have promised a low carbon economy to the world.
Here is a story that will astound you. By 2030, our need for resources will be so high that the story above about the genocide of tribals will sound like child’s play. India will see what happened in America all those years ago when they drove out the Indians. Only magnified a million times. Or should I say 700 million times? Because that is the number of people who will need to be dispossessed of their land, their rights and their very basic right: to live.

All for development’s sake.
All for making more cities like Mumbai which have become gigantic mushrooms feeding off the nation. A mess of proportions so high that most of the people can’t scale the heights with their eyes. So they choose to look the other way.

What was that other Millennium Development goal? Gender?
We are a country where out of 8000 aborted foetuses in a day, 7999 are females. We are a country, the only country where the words female and infanticide co-exist. But let me talk about that in my other posts.

Millennium Development Goals. Tell you what, development as it exists is a term which is like an expired medicine. It makes good placebo. But it can’t cure the cancer that is spreading fast through our society. We cannot have development that is based on consumerism. We need the best minds of our generation to sit down and chalk out an alternative.

What Bill Gates and Monsanto are doing in Africa is not it.

To be continued.

I leave you with a poster based on Arundhati Roy's essay mentioned above. Click to enlarge and read.



Comments

  • Aija Vanaga on 26th April 2010:

    As usual great post from you! Pleasure to read smile


  • Jodi Bush on 26th April 2010:

    Very interesting and thought provoking. It’s strange isn’t it, how we fail to learn from each others mistakes. Like you say, America went through the same transition, making the same errors and with similar results and yet we seem to replicate the same mistakes over and over again. I really enjoyed Arundhati Roy’s essay. Two quotes in particular jumped out at me:

    “Our amazing intelligence seems to have outstripped our instinct for survival.” - how true! It’s like gluttony, or alcoholism, or cleptomania. We know the consequences, but it feels so good while we’re doing it we can’t stop. 

    “Repression ‘through proper channels’ sometimes engenders resistance ‘through proper channels’”. - again, very true. If you want to stand up for what you believe in you have to find an acceptable channel otherwise you’ll be totally disregarded.

    Great poster as well btw.


  • Daniel Nylin Nilsson on 26th April 2010:

    Outstanding post! You describe the connections between business, politics and natural resources in a really clear cut way. But it is also a scary read :(


  • Hemant Jain on 30th April 2010:

    Thanks guys.
    It is indeed scary. My part 2 of this will have a video which my friend shot. The consumerist culture in India. Damn, things are bad.


  • Anca Gheorghica on 02nd May 2010:

    Remarkable and touching post.Looking forward to read the next one.


  • Hieke van der Vaart on 03rd May 2010:

    Uf. You made me think.


  • Hemant Jain on 23rd May 2010:

    This article has now been published here: http://www.ecowalkthetalk.com/blog/2010/05/22/there-should-only-be-one-millennium-development-goal-redefine-development/


  • Ivaylo Vasilev on 23rd May 2010:

    It’s a good article. I like your articles smile


Post your comment

  • Remember my personal information

    Notify me of follow-up comments?

    --- Let's see if you are human ---

    What is the capital of Japan: Paris, New York, Rome or Tokyo? Add a questionmark to your answer. (6 character(s) required)